Attachment to Independent Case .Review Report For CDRU #eBeS Case file #7-17830. _ 4B

Material Examiner: Malone (RQ)

Remarks:

Case resulted in both guilty plea and trial, testimony transcript not provided.

CRM-29190

‘INDEPENDENT CASE REVIEW REPORT

Independent Review conducted by: ~ Steve Robertson

Area(s) of Expertise: Hair and Fiber

Review commenced at: 10:00 AM (Time), 12/04/03 (Wate)

SnnTTTnSnSOE vr File #: 7-17830

Laboratory #(s): * 90830010, 90831023, 90904074 90918010 91113057 BT eae Bee en ee ee a

Examiner(s) & Symbols

Reviewed Not Reviewed Reviewed Not Reviewed

xa po Q. 5 oO

a oO

TR, UY Q xa

a a o

eee ee eee ee pe ee Materials Reviewed 2 2 ee

Trial testimony transcript(s) of: None

Testimony Date(s):

Laboratory Report(s):

Laboratory Number: 90830010, 90831023, 90904074 Date: Sept. 28, 1979

Laboratory Number: 90918010 Date: Oct. 15, 1979 Laboratory Number: 91113057 Date: Nov. 30, 1979

RQ 90830010, 90831023, 90904074

Examiner Bench Notes of:

Laboratory Number:

90918010 91113057

Page 1 of 3

<4 ¢ Initials: §=§ WU

. -CRM-29194

Was any other material reviewed? XO Yes O No

If yes, please identify and/or describe the material: submitting agency letters dated 8/27/79, 8/29/79,

8/31/79, 9/11/79 and 11/8/79. ap rN LL eee

Results of Review File #: 7-17830 Item or Specimen # Reviewed: Q1-14, Q16-Q24, Q29A-Q29D,

K1, K2, K5, K9, K10, K13, K14 : ; Review of Laboratory Report(s) and Bench Notes:

Note: Numbered comments are required below or on additional pages for any "No" or “Unable to Determine" Responses

Did the examiner perform the appropriate tests in a scientifically acceptable manner, based on the methods, protocols, and analytic techniques available at the time of the original examination(s)? Q Yes ONo XO Unable to Determine

Are the examination results set forth in the laboratory report(s) supported and adequately documented in the bench notes? . OYes XONo JO Unable to Determine

a a we ar ee ee Review of Testimony: *

Note: Numbered comments are required below or on additional pages for any "No" or "Unable to Determine" Responses

Xo Transcript not available. 3) Testimony consistent with the laboratory report(s)? OYes ONo O Unable to Determine 4) Testimony consistent with the bench notes? OYes ONo OG Unable to Determine

5) Testimony within bounds of examiner's expertise? oYes ONo O Unable to Determine